Imagine you’re assembling a puzzle. You have all the pieces in front of you, but no picture on the box to guide you. You start putting pieces together, but it feels overwhelming. This is what life can feel like for individuals with delays in executive functioning (EF) skills. As behavior analysts, we’re trained to use evidence-based methods to teach observable behaviors. But EF skills, often described as the “CEO of the brain,” can feel abstract and elusive.
This blog post breaks down how to assess, prioritize, and teach EF skills systematically. Whether you’re working in schools, clinics, or homes, these strategies will help you empower clients to achieve independence and resilience in everyday life.
What Are Executive Functioning Skills?
Executive functioning refers to a set of cognitive processes that enable individuals to plan, focus attention, remember instructions, and manage multiple tasks. These skills include:
- Inhibitory Control: The ability to pause and think before acting.
- Working Memory: Holding and manipulating information in the mind.
- Cognitive Flexibility: Adapting to new situations and perspectives.
- Planning and Organization: Setting goals and managing materials.
- Task Initiation: Starting tasks without excessive prompting.
- Self-Monitoring: Evaluating and adjusting performance.
- Emotional Regulation: Managing frustration and recovering from setbacks.
Delays in EF skills can manifest as difficulties in completing tasks, managing emotions, or adapting to change. Without intervention, these challenges may persist into adulthood, affecting academic, social, and vocational outcomes.
The Challenges of Executive Functioning Delays
For individuals with EF delays, everyday tasks can feel overwhelming:
- Transitions: Moving from one activity to another might trigger frustration or refusal, especially when routines change unexpectedly.
- Multi-Step Directions: Instructions like “Put your shoes on, grab your backpack, and meet me at the door” can result in only one step being completed.
- Frustration Tolerance: Minor setbacks, like losing a turn in a game, can escalate into emotional outbursts.
- Organization: A disorganized workspace or backpack might lead to lost assignments and missed deadlines.
These difficulties are often misinterpreted as defiance or laziness. However, behavior analysts recognize that these are skill deficits—not intentional behaviors. By addressing these deficits, we can equip individuals to navigate life’s challenges with confidence.
The Five-Step Framework for Teaching EF Skills
To address EF skill delays effectively, we follow a structured five-step framework:
Step 1: Assessing Executive Functioning Skills
Assessing EF skills is the foundation of effective intervention. A comprehensive assessment helps pinpoint where breakdowns occur and provides a roadmap for prioritizing goals. Here’s how to approach this crucial step.
Identifying EF Deficits
Behavior analysts should observe and analyze patterns in the learner’s behavior to identify potential EF skill gaps. For example:
- Does the learner struggle to follow multi-step directions? (Working Memory)
- Are transitions between activities met with resistance? (Cognitive Flexibility)
- Does the learner react impulsively in group settings? (Inhibitory Control)
Assessment Tools
Using standardized tools and direct observation ensures accurate identification of EF deficits. Common tools include:
- Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF-2): Measures EF strengths and weaknesses across multiple domains.
- Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC): Evaluates emotional regulation and cognitive processing.
- Naturalistic Observation: Provides real-world insights into how EF challenges manifest in daily activities.
Collecting Meaningful Data
Data collection is vital to understanding the learner’s baseline performance. Strategies include:
- Task Analyses: Break down complex activities into smaller steps and document where the learner experiences challenges.
- Frequency and Duration Measures: Track how often or how long EF-related behaviors occur (e.g., time spent initiating tasks).
- Collaboration with Stakeholders: Gather input from parents, teachers, and other caregivers to build a holistic picture of the learner’s needs.
By conducting thorough assessments, you can design interventions that address the learner’s most pressing needs and set the stage for meaningful skill acquisition.
Step 2: Identify and Prioritize Goals That Have the Greatest Impact
Identifying and prioritizing goals is a critical step in ensuring that intervention efforts yield meaningful and lasting outcomes. Here’s how to approach this step effectively:
Determining High-Impact EF Deficits
Some executive functioning deficits have a greater influence on daily life than others. For example:
- Difficulty with task initiation may prevent the learner from starting homework or chores independently.
- Challenges with emotional regulation can lead to frequent meltdowns, impacting social relationships and family dynamics.
- Struggles with working memory may cause the learner to forget steps in a sequence, like completing a morning routine.
By observing patterns in behavior and gathering input from stakeholders, BCBAs® can identify which deficits are most disruptive to the learner’s goals.
Prioritizing Skills with the Biggest Functional Gains
Once high-impact deficits are identified, it’s essential to prioritize the skills that:
- Promote independence: Skills like planning and organization enable learners to complete tasks with less support.
- Generalize easily: Focus on goals that are likely to be used across multiple settings, such as self-monitoring or cognitive flexibility.
- Meet immediate needs: Address deficits that cause significant barriers to the learner’s daily functioning or emotional well-being.
Setting Clear, Measurable Goals
Effective goals are specific, observable, and tied to meaningful outcomes. Examples include:
- “The learner will independently repeat back a set of 2-3 instructions before completing a task during four out of five opportunities.”
- “The learner will choose a calming strategy, such as deep breathing, during moments of frustration in 80% of observed instances.”
- “The learner will demonstrate the ability to adjust to a change in routine by selecting an alternative activity without prompts in three out of five trials.”
By aligning goals with both the learner’s needs and medical necessity criteria, BCBAs® can ensure that interventions are impactful, ethical, and aligned with evidence-based practices.
Not all EF deficits need to be addressed at once. Some have a bigger impact on daily functioning than others. This step involves:
- Determining which EF deficits are holding your learner back the most.
- Prioritizing skills that will lead to the biggest functional gains.
- Setting clear, measurable goals that meet medical necessity criteria for inclusion in treatment plans.
Step 3: Breaking EF Skills into Observable Behaviors
To teach EF skills, we first need to make them concrete and measurable. Here’s how:
1. Inhibitory Control
Observable Behaviors:
- Pauses before answering a question in group settings.
- Waits for a turn in a game without grabbing items.
- Follows a “pause” or “wait” cue during activities.
2. Working Memory
Observable Behaviors:
- Repeats back multi-step instructions before starting a task.
- Uses a checklist to complete multi-step activities.
- Holds relevant details in mind during conversations or games.
3. Cognitive Flexibility
Observable Behaviors:
- Transitions between activities with minimal protest.
- Accepts changes in routine without distress.
- Chooses an alternative when a preferred option is unavailable.
4. Planning and Organization
Observable Behaviors:
- Creates a to-do list and follows through.
- Organizes materials before starting a task.
- Completes tasks in a logical sequence.
5. Task Initiation
Observable Behaviors:
- Begins a task within 30 seconds of receiving an instruction.
- Asks for help when unsure how to start.
- Uses a prompt-free routine to initiate tasks.
6. Self-Monitoring
Observable Behaviors:
- Checks work before submitting it.
- Notices and corrects mistakes independently.
- Uses feedback to improve performance.
7. Emotional Regulation
Observable Behaviors:
- Uses a calming strategy during frustration (e.g., deep breaths, sensory tools).
- Recovers from setbacks without meltdowns.
- Expresses emotions appropriately.
Step 4: Embed EF Skills into Play
Leverage Preferred Activities and Interests
Understanding a child’s interests is foundational to embedding EF skills into play. For instance:
- If a child loves building with blocks, use block play to teach planning and organization by having them follow a visual blueprint.
- If a child enjoys pretend play, create scenarios that promote flexibility by introducing unexpected changes, like a detour on a pretend road trip.
- For children fascinated by superheroes, incorporate task initiation by having them “complete a mission” when given a visual or verbal prompt.
Integrate Play-Based Activities for EF Skill Development
Here’s how to embed specific EF skills into various types of play:
1. Inhibitory Control:
- Red Light, Green Light: Teach impulse control by varying the timing of your signals, requiring the child to stop and start on command.
- Bubble Freeze: Blow bubbles and prompt the child to wait until a specific cue before popping them.
2. Working Memory:
- Treasure Hunt: Provide a series of verbal or visual clues the child must remember and follow to find a hidden object.
- Simon Says: Gradually increase the complexity of commands to enhance memory retention and recall.
3. Cognitive Flexibility:
- Obstacle Courses: Change the course mid-play and prompt the child to adapt their strategy.
- Switch Roles in Pretend Play: Encourage the child to switch between different characters or responsibilities within the scenario.
4. Planning and Organization:
- Build It Challenges: Provide materials and a picture of a structure for the child to replicate, requiring them to plan and organize their approach.
- Prepare a Meal in Pretend Play: Have the child plan the steps needed to “cook” and serve a pretend meal.
5. Task Initiation:
- Mystery Bag Game: Place an object in a bag and prompt the child to initiate a game or task based on the item they pull out.
- Race to Start: Create a playful competition where the goal is to start a specific task quickly and correctly.
6. Self-Monitoring:
- Puzzle Detective: Include mismatched puzzle pieces and ask the child to identify and correct errors as they complete the task.
- Checkpoint Games: Pause during activities and have the child assess their progress against a set goal.
7. Emotional Regulation:
- Feelings Freeze: Call out different emotions. Have the child freeze then act them out.
- Bounce-Back Challenge: Turn bouncing back from frustrating moments into a game. Create small, frustrating situations to practice.
Use Reinforcement Strategically
Incorporate reinforcement strategies that align with the child’s preferences to increase motivation. As much as possible, allow natural contingencies to shape behavior. For example:
- Completing a treasure hunt that leads to a highly preferred activity.
- Successfully completing a complex puzzle.
- Provide access to a highly preferred activity (e.g., extra playtime) after the child demonstrates a target EF skill.
- Use specific praise, such as, “I love how you remembered all the steps to complete the treasure hunt!”
Step 5: Generalizing EF Skills
Generalization is critical for ensuring EF skills are used across environments, with different people, and in everyday contexts. Without generalization, learners may demonstrate skills only in therapy sessions but struggle to apply them elsewhere. Here’s how to make sure EF skills transfer effectively:
Collaborate with Stakeholders
Involving parents, teachers, and caregivers is essential for promoting consistent skill use. Strategies include:
- Parent Training: Teach parents how to reinforce EF skills at home through everyday routines, like cooking or bedtime preparation.
- School Collaboration: Work with teachers to integrate EF goals into classroom activities and accommodations, such as using visual schedules or checklists.
- Community Engagement: Partner with community members, such as coaches or group leaders, to support EF skill practice during extracurricular activities.
Expand Practice Across Settings
Learners should practice EF skills in various locations to enhance flexibility and adaptability. Ideas include:
- Home: Encourage parents to use natural opportunities, like meal prep, to practice planning and sequencing.
- School: Incorporate EF tasks into academic activities, such as organizing materials for a science experiment.
- Community: Practice self-monitoring and emotional regulation during outings, like grocery shopping or attending events.
Embed Natural Reinforcers
Natural reinforcement helps learners see the value of EF skills in real-life contexts. For example:
- Task Completion: Praise or reward completing a complex task, like cleaning a room, with access to a preferred activity.
- Positive Feedback: Use immediate, specific feedback, such as “You did a great job remembering all the steps to set the table.”
Use Generalization Strategies
Apply evidence-based strategies to promote skill maintenance across environments:
- Stimulus Generalization: Vary materials, instructions, and settings to help the learner apply skills flexibly.
- Response Generalization: Reinforce different ways of achieving the same goal, like using either a timer or self-talk for task initiation.
- Peer Modeling: Encourage practice with peers to simulate real-world scenarios and social contexts.
Monitor Progress and Adjust
Track how well EF skills are being applied in different contexts. Use data to:
- Identify settings or situations where additional support is needed.
- Gradually fade prompts and reinforcement to encourage independence.
- Celebrate successes to build confidence and motivation.
By focusing on collaboration, varied practice, and natural reinforcement, BCBAs® can ensure EF skills are not only learned but also maintained and generalized, leading to greater independence and success for learners in their everyday lives.
Pulling It All Together
This table summarizes key executive functioning skills alongside measurable goals, engaging activities to teach these skills, and strategies to promote generalization. By using this framework, behavior analysts can seamlessly integrate EF skill development into play and ensure learners can apply these abilities across diverse settings and situations.
EF Skill | Goal | Activity | Generalization |
---|---|---|---|
Inhibitory Control | Waits for a turn during a group activity without grabbing items. | Red Light, Green Light: Child stops and goes based on verbal cues. | Use the skill during board games at home or school. |
Working Memory | Follows a three-step verbal direction. | Treasure Hunt: Child remembers and follows clues to find an item. | Apply the skill during classroom instructions or daily routines. |
Cognitive Flexibility | Adapts to changes in a planned activity without protest. | Obstacle Course: Modify the path mid-way, prompting adjustments. | Use the skill during unexpected transitions in routines. |
Planning and Organization | Creates a to-do list and completes tasks in sequence. | Build It Challenge: Follow a blueprint to construct a tower with blocks. | Practice sequencing skills during homework or chores. |
Task Initiation | Begins a task within 30 seconds of receiving an instruction. | Mystery Bag Game: Starts play using a surprise object promptly. | Initiate tasks like packing a school bag or starting a worksheet. |
Self-Monitoring | Identifies and corrects errors in a task independently. | Detective Work: Finds mismatched puzzle pieces and corrects them. | Self-checks completed work in class or home assignments. |
Emotional Regulation | Uses calming strategies during moments of frustration. | Feelings Role-Play: Practices calming tools with action figures. | Applies calming tools during conflicts with peers or in new settings. |
Take the Next Step
Executive functioning skills are essential for independence, problem-solving, and resilience. With ABA’s systematic approach, we can teach these skills effectively, empowering learners to navigate life’s challenges with confidence.
To dive deeper into practical strategies and frameworks for teaching EF skills, enroll in our CEU course, “Think, Plan, Do: How to Teach Flexibility, Memory, and Self-Control“ Gain actionable insights, earn CEUs, and transform your approach to fostering independence.
For additional resources, check out:
- Nurturing Executive Functioning Skills in Autistic Individuals
- Generalization: The Key to Meaningful Programming in ABA
- Importance of Targeting Pivotal Behaviors and Behavior Cusps in ABA: Key Strategies for Effective Intervention Plans
Together, let’s build the skills that unlock true independence.
References
Bahry, S., Gerhardt, P. F., Weiss, M. J., Leaf, J. B., Putnam, R. F., & Bondy, A. (2023). The ethics of actually helping people: Targeting skill acquisition goals that promote meaningful outcomes for individuals with autism spectrum disorder. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 16(3), 672-695.
Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. (2011). Building the brain’s “air traffic control” system: How early experiences shape the development of executive function (Working Paper No. 11). Retrieved from www.developingchild.harvard.edu.
Dawson, P., & Guare, R. (2011). Smart but scattered: The revolutionary “executive skills” approach to helping kids reach their potential. Guilford Press.
McCloskey, G., Perkins, L. A., & Van Diviner, B. (2008). Assessment and intervention for executive function difficulties. Routledge.
Najdowski, A. C. (2016). Flexible and focused: Teaching executive function skills to individuals with autism and attention disorders. Academic Press.
Ozonoff, S., & Schetter, P. L. (2007). Executive dysfunction in autism spectrum disorders. In L. Meltzer (Ed.), Executive function in education: From theory to practice (pp. 133-160). Guilford Press.
Saniee, S., Pouretemad, H. R., & Zardkhaneh, S. A. (2019). Developing set‐shifting improvement tasks (SSIT) for children with high‐functioning autism. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 63(10), 1207-1220.
Tababaienavainobari, P., Soleymani, M., & Shalchi, B. (2021). Comparison of the effectiveness of pivotal response treatment and applied behavioral analysis on the symptoms severity and executive functions in autistic children. The Neuroscience Journal of Shefaye Khatam, 9(2), 22-34.
Ward, S., & Jacobsen, K. (2014). A clinical model for developing executive function skills. Perspectives on Language Learning and Education, 21(2), 72-84.
Yellow Bus ABA. (n.d.). How ABA therapy enhances executive functioning skills in children with autism. Retrieved from https://www.yellowbusaba.com/post/how-aba-therapy-enhances-executive-functioning-skills-in-children-with-autism.